How to Choose a Sealant?
There are many types of sealants available, each comes with different properties and is intended for specific applications. Some mass-market products are available at retail outlets, while some others are only supplied by manufacturers / distributors directly to construction or industrial users. Due to certain factors, some sealant products are only available in certain countries / regions.
The continuous R&D in sealant technologies also have made newer and better products available to the public, obsoleting the predecessors. Likewise, the implementation of new regulations, such as the requirement for training to use polyurethane products in Europe as enforced by the European Union since August 2023, could lead to a paradigm shift away from using such products.
Sealant Types and Common Uses:
Sealant Type | Characteristics | Common Uses |
Acetoxy Silicone | Good adhesion, fast curing, budget-friendly. Choose a 100% version for better performance expectation if cost is not a concern. | General-purpose sealing |
Neutral Silicone | Odorless, flexible, good adhesion, good weathering. Choose a 100% version for better performance expectation if cost is not a concern. | Windows & doors Weatherseal (glass) Kitchens, bathrooms (antifungal) Metal Roofing, flashing, gutter, etc. |
MS Polymer / STP / SMP / STPE / Hybrid | Paintable, good adhesion, flexible, weathering resistant, paintable, green | Movement joints, windows & doors perimeter |
Acrylic Latex | Paintable, easy application, budget-friendly | Interior sealing, trim, windows, doors |
Awning Caulk | Oil based sealant that skins but does not cure. Easy application, budget-friendly. Available in certain countries only. | Awning & gutter. Less movement expected. |
Polyurethane | High elasticity, good adhesion, paintable | Movement joints require painting |
Polysulfide | Water and chemicals resistant formulations available, not weathering or movement resistant. Less common in general joint sealing anymore. | Joints subject to water immersion or chemical attacks. |
Acrylic | Uncommon. Expensive. Very flexible and weathering resistant. Also comes with clear color. | Polycarbonate sealing. |
Siliconized Acrylic | Common in the US / Europe, which combines the properties of silicone sealants and acrylic latex sealants. However, its weathering performance is still not as good as pure silicone sealants. | General joint sealing without exposed to harsh weather in long term. |
Butyl | Uncommon. Does not cure like other sealants but retains a gum-like consistency. Water resistant but not abrasion resistant. | gutters, corrugated roofing and automotive windshield sealing |
Choosing the Right Sealant: Key Criteria
Selecting the appropriate sealant for a specific application is crucial to ensure its longevity and effectiveness. Here are the primary factors to consider:
1. Workability Requirements:
1.1 Skin Form and Curing time: The desired curing time depends on the application. Acetoxy silicone sealants cure faster than neutral ones. MS Polymer sealants cure faster than Polyurethane sealants. Acrylic latex sealants always cure the slowest due to slower water evaporation process.
1.2 Paintability: If the sealant needs to be painted, choose a paintable type. Silicone sealants are not paintable.
1.3 Mixing: Although uncommon at retail outlets, sealants that come in 2 components (resin + hardener) exist. They require mixing before use, something that is best avoided due to higher chances of human errors. However, these 2K products that are still in use today do have their merits, like shorter cure-through time.
2. Service Requirements:
2.1 Substrate Compatibility: the sealant must adhere well to the surfaces it will be applied to (e.g., metal, glass, wood, concrete, etc.). Certain sealants might be incompatible with some substrates.
For example, acetoxy silicone sealant should not be used on concrete, mortar, or natural stone substrates due to the alkaline nature of these substrates, which would cause issues like adhesion failure or discoloration after a while. Likewise, acetoxy silicone sealants also should not be used on metal or mirrors due to its corrosive nature.
As for plastics, MS Polymer sealants would stand a higher chance of successful adhesion compared with other types of sealants (nothing bonds on PP, PE, PTFE).
Glass – never use a non-silicone type of sealant to seal glasses, due to UV ray that shines through glass and gets refracted will damage the bonding line of all sealants – except silicone sealants.
Laminated Glass – the PVB inter layer film might have edge / corner delaminates (bubbling) issue because of incompatible with certain silicone sealants. Depending on specific formulations, not all silicone sealant of the same brand would be compatible with specific PVB film. A compatibility test is always recommended.
2.2 Movement and Flexibility:
- Joint movement: Consider the expected movement in the joint (static, dynamic, or cyclic).
- Sealant elasticity: The sealant’s flexibility should match the joint movement to prevent cracking or failure.
- Basically, if the joints are anticipated to have great movements, due to whatever reasons like thermal or structural movements of the buildings, less flexible options like acrylic latex sealants or awning caulk should be avoided.
2.3. Environmental Conditions:
- Weather exposure: Sealants for exterior use must withstand UV rays, rain, wind, and temperature extremes. Budget-friendly acrylic latex sealants should always be avoided because they are mostly intended for indoor use only. If the exterior applications of sealants are applied in such a way that the sealant thickness is less than 6mm, or in a non-joint setting like sealing fasteners on roofing, avoid the use of organic sealants like Polyurethane sealants or even MS Polymer sealants. Neutral silicone sealants are always the best bet in terms of weathering.
- Chemical resistance: If the sealant will be exposed to chemicals, choose one with appropriate resistance. The problem is, there are too many types of chemicals available out there, and each sealant has different formulations that would react to a particular chemical differently. Therefore, a compatibility test is recommended if the sealing is mission critical.
- Temperature range: Consider the sealant’s performance at both high and low temperatures. Generally, Acrylic latex sealants withstand temperatures up to 80°C, MS Polymer sealants – up to 90°C, and silicone sealants – up to 150°C. Refer to TDS of the particular product to confirm.
- Water immersion: Most common sealants available on the market are not permanently water immersible (intermittent wet and dry is OK). Among them, silicone sealants stand the best chance of withstanding water immersion. However, it still depends on the type of adjacent substrates being bonded as the bonding line always fails on wet porous substrates.
- Wet environments with bad ventilations: where fungal growth is common, antifungal sealants are preferred, although they only withstand longer if there is always organic residue like soap foam left on the surface, with bad ventilation and wet conditions, which are perfect recipe of fungal growth.
- Traffic Abrasion: Is the joint located at pedestrian walkways that are subject to human traffic? Or at driveway, airport runway, or factory areas subject to vehicular traffic abrasion? In short, sealants for traffic joints should have high hardness properties and great adhesion to the joint flanks, so it can live up to the challenge. However, no matter how good a sealant is, protecting the sealant with a cover is always recommended.
- Vibrations: Is the sealant joint subject to constant vibrations during its service life? For example, sealing joints in commercial vehicles (industrial manufacturing) requires a sealant with higher tensile strength.
- Low Emission: While it is a common requirement to use sealants with low VOC (volatile organic compounds) in green buildings, it is even more stringent these days that sealants need to exhibit low emissions characteristic in new green building standards, like LEED v4.1. Likewise, sealants used in semiconductor cleanrooms need to have extremely low emissions so as not to affect the manufacturing process, in compliance with the specific ISO Clean Room Classifications.
- Contact with Food / Drinking Water: Sealing a confectionery showcase, glass refrigerator, water dispenser, or even a steel water tank? There are specific tests and standards that can confirm the sealants are safe for use in such conditions – that they will not leach harmful materials into food or water when in contact.
2.4. Purpose of applications:
Purpose: The sealant’s primary function (e.g., waterproofing, bonding, sealing gaps) will determine the type to use. For example, if you are sealing glass panels to prevent rainwater leaks in to the building from outside, you choose a neutral silicone sealant that has good extrusion, low modulus, good elongation or movement capability, so it makes applications easier, and the sealant is durable under weathering conditions.
On the contrary, if you only need to seal the small gaps on the wood skirting baseboard in your house, an acrylic latex sealant will do the job just fine, yet it is easy to apply and clean.
There are also requirements where sealants need to be fire-rated, due to the joints or voids to be sealed are part of a systems that need to be fireproof, like fire doors, fire ducts, etc. Choose only fire rated sealants in such circumstances.
2.5 Compliance
Industry standards: Adhere to relevant industry standards and regulations. Some environments may need the sealants to comply with certain standards. A LEED building would need the joints in building to be sealed with a LEED-compliant sealant. Likewise, joints in some buildings might need to seal with FM-certified sealant due to insurance requirements. Choose a product that complies with such requirements before it is used.
2.6 Aesthetics
Color: Very often sealant of specific color is needed to match the color of adjacent substrate, like window frame.
Texture: Although uncommon, sealants come with certain texture like stone or glitter texture exist. There might be also some fillers that can be sanded. “Sealants” are normally rubbery and flexible in nature, thus typically not sandable.
3.0 Costs
While Acrylic latex sealants might be a more cost-effective option, if it was used in the wrong applications, it potentially incurs repair costs higher than what one would pay for the right sealant chosen from the beginning.
Additionally, it is not only the cost of sealant material that should be taken in consideration, but the cost of maintenance ensued in the years of service should be considered too. One might choose low-cost silicone sealants that are costed down with mineral oil for a cladding project, causing severe oil staining issues on the cladding from time to time, incurring great façade cleaning costs.
So please choose the right type of sealant from the beginning.
Always refer to the product TDS for specific details.